Weak Points of Kurnia Bus and PMTOH Bus

Oct 13, 2025 by wbrum.org 0 views

Analysis of Bus Service Performance with Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) Method: Case Study of Kurnia Bus and PMTOH Bus

Introduction

Transportation is the backbone of development, playing a crucial role in supporting economic activities and regional development. A good transportation system is expected to increase population and resource mobility, encourage economic growth, and eliminate insulation between regions. This opens opportunities for progress in various fields, including trade, industry, and other sectors. As a mobility service provider, buses have a crucial role in moving humans, goods, and resources. Therefore, the government sets a minimum service standard that must be met by public transport companies, contained in the Regulation of the Minister of Transportation of the Republic of Indonesia Number PM. 10 of 2012. This standard aims to ensure passenger satisfaction and improve service quality.

Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) Method

The Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) method is an effective analysis tool to measure customer satisfaction by identifying service aspects that are considered important by customers and how well the service is carried out. By analyzing the important aspects and performance of each aspect, the IPA method helps identify areas that need to be improved to increase customer satisfaction. The IPA method is widely used in various industries, including transportation, to evaluate the performance of services and identify areas for improvement.

Case Study: Kurnia Bus and PMTOH Bus

The results of research conducted on the Kurnia buses and PMTOH bus revealed that the quality of the services of the two buses was still not satisfactory. This can be seen from the average value of services that are at 2-3 (using the IPA method), while the satisfactory service value is 4-5. The science method itself is an effective analysis tool to measure customer satisfaction by identifying service aspects that are considered important by customers and how well the service is carried out.

Weak Points of Kurnia Bus and PMTOH Bus

The results of the science analysis show that there are several aspects of service that are the weak points of the two bus companies. Among others are:

Timeliness: The bus delay periodically is the main problem. This is caused by various factors, such as traffic conditions, vehicle damage, and lack of discipline in running the schedule.
Safety: Safety factor is also a major concern for passengers. The condition of the bus that is poorly maintained, the lack of supervision, and unprofessional behavior of the driver becomes several factors that can threaten the safety of passengers.
Comfort: The state of the chair, the cleanliness of the bus, and inadequate air circulation is a factor that affects the comfort of passengers during the trip.
Availability of facilities: Supporting facilities such as toilets, air conditioners, and inadequate or non-functioning trash bins are also important points that need attention.

Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI)

In addition to the science method, research also uses the Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) which shows a value of 62.48% for Kurnia buses and 60.55% for PMTOH buses. This figure shows that passenger satisfaction with the services of the two buses has not yet reached the optimal level.

Solution to Improve the Quality of Bus Services

Based on the results of science and CSI analysis, here are some solutions that can be implemented by the Kurnia Bus and PMTOH bus to improve the quality of services and passenger satisfaction:

Increasing timeliness:
- Improve the time management system and schedule by calculating traffic conditions and delays.
- Strengthening the driver's discipline in running the schedule.
- Improve communication and information systems to passengers regarding schedule changes or delays.
Improve security:
- Conduct routine checks and maintenance of bus conditions.
- Tightening the supervision and training of drivers to improve professionalism and discipline.
- Provides security facilities such as surveillance cameras and emergency buttons.
Increasing comfort:
- Improve the condition of the chair and the cleanliness of the bus regularly.
- Increase air circulation and lighting on the bus.
- Provides entertainment and comfort facilities such as TV, WiFi, and trash bins.
Increasing the availability of facilities:
- Provides clean and adequate toilets and trash bins.
- Ensuring AC is functioning properly and provides electricity sources to charge electronic devices.
- Increase accessibility for disabled passengers.

Conclusion

By applying the solution, the Kurnia Bus and PMTOH bus can improve service quality, increase passenger satisfaction, and gain trust from the community. This will have a positive impact on increasing the use of bus transportation services, economic growth in the region, and the welfare of the community.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Analyzing Bus Service Performance with Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) Method

Introduction

In our previous article, we discussed the importance of analyzing bus service performance using the Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) method. We also presented a case study of Kurnia Bus and PMTOH Bus, highlighting their weak points and providing solutions to improve their services. In this article, we will answer some frequently asked questions (FAQs) about analyzing bus service performance with the IPA method.

Q&A

Q1: What is the Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) method?

A1: The Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) method is a tool used to measure customer satisfaction by identifying service aspects that are considered important by customers and how well the service is carried out.

Q2: Why is the IPA method important in analyzing bus service performance?

A2: The IPA method is important in analyzing bus service performance because it helps identify areas that need to be improved to increase customer satisfaction. By analyzing the important aspects and performance of each aspect, the IPA method provides a comprehensive understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of a bus service.

Q3: What are the key factors that affect bus service performance?

A3: The key factors that affect bus service performance include timeliness, safety, comfort, and availability of facilities. These factors are critical in determining the overall satisfaction of passengers with a bus service.

Q4: How can bus companies use the IPA method to improve their services?

A4: Bus companies can use the IPA method to identify areas that need improvement and develop strategies to address these issues. By analyzing the important aspects and performance of each aspect, bus companies can prioritize their efforts and resources to improve their services.

Q5: What are some common challenges faced by bus companies in improving their services?

A5: Some common challenges faced by bus companies in improving their services include lack of resources, inadequate infrastructure, and limited customer feedback. Bus companies must address these challenges to improve their services and increase customer satisfaction.

Q6: How can bus companies measure customer satisfaction using the IPA method?

A6: Bus companies can measure customer satisfaction using the IPA method by collecting data on customer feedback and ratings. This data can be used to identify areas that need improvement and develop strategies to address these issues.

Q7: What are some benefits of using the IPA method in analyzing bus service performance?

A7: Some benefits of using the IPA method in analyzing bus service performance include improved customer satisfaction, increased loyalty, and enhanced reputation. By using the IPA method, bus companies can identify areas that need improvement and develop strategies to address these issues.

Q8: Can the IPA method be used in other industries besides transportation?

A8: Yes, the IPA method can be used in other industries besides transportation. The IPA method is a versatile tool that can be applied to various industries, including healthcare, finance, and retail.

Q9: How can bus companies use the IPA method to identify opportunities for growth and expansion?

A9: Bus companies can use the IPA method to identify opportunities for growth and expansion by analyzing customer feedback and ratings. This data can be used to identify areas that need improvement and develop strategies to address these issues.

Q10: What are some best practices for implementing the IPA method in analyzing bus service performance?

A10: Some best practices for implementing the IPA method in analyzing bus service performance include collecting data on customer feedback and ratings, analyzing the important aspects and performance of each aspect, and developing strategies to address areas that need improvement.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Importance Performance Analysis (IPA) method is a powerful tool for analyzing bus service performance. By using the IPA method, bus companies can identify areas that need improvement and develop strategies to address these issues. We hope that this article has provided valuable insights and information on using the IPA method in analyzing bus service performance.