The Regulation of Polygamy in Islamic Fiqh and Indonesian Law

Oct 13, 2025 by wbrum.org 94 views

Polygamy More than Four: Perspective of Islamic Fiqh and Law Number 1 of 1974

Polygamy is a form of marriage in which a husband has more than one wife, based on Islamic law has a foundation in the Qur'an, especially in the An-Nisa verses 3 and 129, as well as the hadith narrated by HR Ahmad. However, in the context of positive law in Indonesia, Law Number 1 of 1974 concerning Marriage confirms that a husband is only allowed to have a maximum of four wives. If a husband has more than four wives, the marriage is considered adultery and illegal. Understanding the complexities of polygamy in Islamic law and Indonesian law is crucial in addressing the social and moral implications of this practice.

The Regulation of Polygamy in Islamic Fiqh and Indonesian Law

In Islamic jurisprudence, polygamy is allowed under certain conditions, as stated in the Qur'an and hadith. However, the practice of polygamy is subject to certain rules and regulations, including the requirement that the husband must be able to provide fair treatment to all his wives. The concept of justice and responsibility is a fundamental principle in Islamic law, and polygamy is no exception. In contrast, Indonesian law, as stated in Law Number 1 of 1974, limits the number of wives a husband can have to four. The legal implications of polygamy in Indonesia are clear: any marriage that exceeds this limit is considered adultery and is therefore illegal.

The Legality of Polygamy Status that Exceeds Four Wives

The legality of polygamy status that exceeds four wives is a complex issue that raises various social and moral problems. From a legal perspective, any marriage that exceeds the limit of four wives is considered adultery and is therefore illegal. However, in practice, many couples continue to engage in polygamy, often with devastating consequences for the children involved. The social and moral implications of polygamy are far-reaching, and it is essential to address these issues through education and law enforcement.

The Legal Consequences of Polygamy who have More than Four Wives

The legal consequences of polygamy who have more than four wives are severe. According to Law Number 1 of 1974, any marriage that exceeds the limit of four wives is considered adultery and is therefore illegal. This means that the children born from such a marriage will not have a nasab or legal lineage from their father. This can have serious consequences for the children, including their social and economic status.

The Social and Moral Implications of Polygamy

The social and moral implications of polygamy are far-reaching. Polygamy can lead to social and economic problems, including poverty, inequality, and social unrest. It can also lead to moral problems, including the exploitation of women and children. Therefore, it is essential to address these issues through education and law enforcement.

Conclusion

In conclusion, polygamy is a complex issue that raises various social and moral problems. From a legal perspective, any marriage that exceeds the limit of four wives is considered adultery and is therefore illegal. However, in practice, many couples continue to engage in polygamy, often with devastating consequences for the children involved. Therefore, it is essential to address these issues through education and law enforcement to maintain the integrity of marriage values in society.

Recommendations

Based on the analysis above, the following recommendations are made:

Education and awareness: Educational efforts should be made to raise awareness about the legal and social implications of polygamy.
Law enforcement: Law enforcement agencies should be consistent in enforcing the law regarding polygamy.
Social support: Social support should be provided to couples who are affected by polygamy, including counseling and other forms of assistance.
Policy reform: Policy reform should be considered to address the social and moral implications of polygamy.

Future Research Directions

Future research should focus on the following areas:

The social and moral implications of polygamy: Further research should be conducted to understand the social and moral implications of polygamy.
The legal consequences of polygamy: Further research should be conducted to understand the legal consequences of polygamy.
Policy reform: Further research should be conducted to understand the potential policy reforms that could address the social and moral implications of polygamy.

Limitations of the Study

This study has several limitations, including:

Data collection: The data used in this study was limited to secondary sources.
Sample size: The sample size of this study was limited to a small number of cases.
Generalizability: The findings of this study may not be generalizable to other contexts.

Conclusion

Q: What is polygamy in Islamic law?

A: Polygamy in Islamic law is a form of marriage in which a husband has more than one wife. This practice is allowed under certain conditions, as stated in the Qur'an and hadith.

Q: What are the conditions for polygamy in Islamic law?

A: The conditions for polygamy in Islamic law include the requirement that the husband must be able to provide fair treatment to all his wives, and that the marriage must be based on mutual consent.

Q: How many wives can a husband have in Islamic law?

A: In Islamic law, a husband can have up to four wives, provided that he can provide fair treatment to all of them.

Q: What is the legal status of polygamy in Indonesia?

A: In Indonesia, polygamy is regulated by Law Number 1 of 1974 concerning Marriage. According to this law, a husband is only allowed to have a maximum of four wives.

Q: What are the consequences of polygamy in Indonesia?

A: In Indonesia, polygamy that exceeds the limit of four wives is considered adultery and is therefore illegal. This means that the children born from such a marriage will not have a nasab or legal lineage from their father.

Q: Can a husband have more than four wives in Indonesia?

A: No, a husband cannot have more than four wives in Indonesia. According to Law Number 1 of 1974 concerning Marriage, any marriage that exceeds the limit of four wives is considered adultery and is therefore illegal.

Q: What are the social and moral implications of polygamy?

A: The social and moral implications of polygamy are far-reaching. Polygamy can lead to social and economic problems, including poverty, inequality, and social unrest. It can also lead to moral problems, including the exploitation of women and children.

Q: How can the social and moral implications of polygamy be addressed?

A: The social and moral implications of polygamy can be addressed through education and awareness, law enforcement, social support, and policy reform.

Q: What is the role of education in addressing the social and moral implications of polygamy?

A: Education plays a crucial role in addressing the social and moral implications of polygamy. Educational efforts should be made to raise awareness about the legal and social implications of polygamy.

Q: What is the role of law enforcement in addressing the social and moral implications of polygamy?

A: Law enforcement agencies should be consistent in enforcing the law regarding polygamy. This includes investigating and prosecuting cases of polygamy that exceed the limit of four wives.

Q: What is the role of social support in addressing the social and moral implications of polygamy?

A: Social support should be provided to couples who are affected by polygamy, including counseling and other forms of assistance.

Q: What is the role of policy reform in addressing the social and moral implications of polygamy?

A: Policy reform should be considered to address the social and moral implications of polygamy. This includes revising laws and regulations related to polygamy to make them more effective in addressing the social and moral implications of this practice.

Q: What are the limitations of this study?

A: This study has several limitations, including data collection, sample size, and generalizability.

Q: What are the future research directions?

A: Future research should focus on the social and moral implications of polygamy, the legal consequences of polygamy, and policy reform.

Q: What is the conclusion of this study?

A: In conclusion, polygamy is a complex issue that raises various social and moral problems. From a legal perspective, any marriage that exceeds the limit of four wives is considered adultery and is therefore illegal. However, in practice, many couples continue to engage in polygamy, often with devastating consequences for the children involved. Therefore, it is essential to address these issues through education and law enforcement to maintain the integrity of marriage values in society.