The Legal Regulation of Religious Defending Crimes

Oct 13, 2025 by wbrum.org 61 views

Criminal Accountability for the Perpetrators of Criminal Blasphemy: A Study of District Court Decision Number 31/PID.B/2016/PN-SKG

Introduction

Religious blasphemy is a sensitive issue that has been a subject of controversy in many parts of the world, including Indonesia. The country has a diverse population with various religions, and the government has implemented laws to protect the rights of all citizens, including those related to freedom of religion. However, the line between freedom of expression and blasphemy can be blurry, and the consequences of crossing that line can be severe. This article aims to discuss the legal regulation regarding the criminal offenses of religious blasphemy in Indonesia and the criminal responsibility of the perpetrators based on the decision of the Sengkang District Court involving the defendant Makmur bin Amir.

The Legal Regulation of Religious Defending Crimes

In Indonesia, the regulation regarding the crime of blasphemy is regulated in Article 4 of Law No. 1/PNPS/1965, which states that there is a new article in the Criminal Code (KUHP), namely Article 156A. This article explains that a person can be sentenced to a maximum of five years in prison if intentionally issuing feelings or doing acts that are hostility, abuse, or blasphemy of a religion recognized in Indonesia. The seriousness of the state in handling cases of blasphemy is evident in the sensitivity inherent in this issue in society. The government has taken a firm stance on protecting the rights of all citizens, including those related to freedom of religion.

The Importance of Article 156A

Article 156A of the Criminal Code is a crucial provision that outlines the punishment for blasphemy. The article states that a person who intentionally issues feelings or does acts that are hostility, abuse, or blasphemy of a religion recognized in Indonesia can be sentenced to a maximum of five years in prison. This provision is essential in maintaining social harmony and protecting the rights of all citizens. The government has implemented this provision to ensure that individuals who engage in blasphemy are held accountable for their actions.

Criminal Sanctions

Sanctions imposed on the perpetrators of blasphemy, in accordance with Article 156A of the Criminal Code, are imprisonment for five years. In the case of the defendant Makmur bin Amir, he was sentenced to prison for one year and six months. In addition, the detention period that has been undertaken by the defendant will be deducted from the total sentence handed down. This decision reflects the application of law that is proportional to actions that are considered to violate social and religious norms in society.

The Role of the Court

The court plays a crucial role in upholding the law and maintaining social harmony. In the case of Makmur bin Amir, the court must analyze the extent to which the action is detrimental to religious people and create social instability. The court must also consider the intentions and impacts caused by the action. This highlights the importance of in-depth analysis in the judicial process, where the psychological and social aspects of religious blasphemy must be considered.

Criminal Accountability

Criminal accountability for the perpetrators of criminal offenses of religious blasphemy is not only related to the physical actions taken, but must also consider the intentions and impacts caused. In the case of Makmur bin Amir, the court must analyze the extent to which the action is detrimental to religious people and create social instability. This also highlights the importance of in-depth analysis in the judicial process, where the psychological and social aspects of religious blasphemy must be considered.

The Importance of In-Depth Analysis

In-depth analysis is essential in the judicial process, particularly in cases of blasphemy. The court must consider the intentions and impacts caused by the action, as well as the extent to which the action is detrimental to religious people and creates social instability. This approach ensures that the court makes a fair and just decision, taking into account the complexities of the case.

Conclusion

Cases of blasphemy, as happened to Makmur bin Amir, highlighted the challenges in upholding the law and maintaining harmony between religious believers in Indonesia. Existing legal arrangements aim to protect religious values and ensure that actions that have the potential to disrupt the peace of society can be prosecuted. Criminal accountability is an important tool in upholding justice, with the hope of providing a deterrent effect for the perpetrators and maintaining harmony in religious life in Indonesia.

The Way Forward

Through a deep understanding of law and social, it is expected that law enforcement of cases of blasphemy can be carried out fairly and wisely, while encouraging people to respect each other. The government, the court, and the community must work together to maintain social harmony and protect the rights of all citizens. This requires a comprehensive approach that takes into account the complexities of the issue and the needs of all stakeholders.

Recommendations

Based on the analysis of the case of Makmur bin Amir, the following recommendations can be made:

The government should continue to implement laws that protect the rights of all citizens, including those related to freedom of religion.
The court should conduct in-depth analysis in cases of blasphemy, taking into account the intentions and impacts caused by the action.
The community should be educated on the importance of respecting each other's beliefs and values.
The government, the court, and the community should work together to maintain social harmony and protect the rights of all citizens.

By following these recommendations, it is expected that law enforcement of cases of blasphemy can be carried out fairly and wisely, while encouraging people to respect each other.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Criminal Accountability for the Perpetrators of Criminal Blasphemy

Q: What is blasphemy?

A: Blasphemy is an act carried out deliberately to hurt or insult a religion or matters relating to that religion.

Q: What is the legal regulation regarding the crime of blasphemy in Indonesia?

A: The regulation regarding the crime of blasphemy in Indonesia is regulated in Article 4 of Law No. 1/PNPS/1965, which states that there is a new article in the Criminal Code (KUHP), namely Article 156A.

Q: What is the punishment for blasphemy in Indonesia?

A: According to Article 156A of the Criminal Code, a person who intentionally issues feelings or does acts that are hostility, abuse, or blasphemy of a religion recognized in Indonesia can be sentenced to a maximum of five years in prison.

Q: What is the role of the court in cases of blasphemy?

A: The court plays a crucial role in upholding the law and maintaining social harmony. In cases of blasphemy, the court must analyze the extent to which the action is detrimental to religious people and create social instability.

Q: What is the importance of in-depth analysis in the judicial process?

A: In-depth analysis is essential in the judicial process, particularly in cases of blasphemy. The court must consider the intentions and impacts caused by the action, as well as the extent to which the action is detrimental to religious people and creates social instability.

Q: What is the way forward in maintaining social harmony and protecting the rights of all citizens?

A: Through a deep understanding of law and social, it is expected that law enforcement of cases of blasphemy can be carried out fairly and wisely, while encouraging people to respect each other. The government, the court, and the community must work together to maintain social harmony and protect the rights of all citizens.

Q: What are the recommendations for maintaining social harmony and protecting the rights of all citizens?

A: Based on the analysis of the case of Makmur bin Amir, the following recommendations can be made:

The government should continue to implement laws that protect the rights of all citizens, including those related to freedom of religion.
The court should conduct in-depth analysis in cases of blasphemy, taking into account the intentions and impacts caused by the action.
The community should be educated on the importance of respecting each other's beliefs and values.
The government, the court, and the community should work together to maintain social harmony and protect the rights of all citizens.

Q: What is the significance of the case of Makmur bin Amir?

A: The case of Makmur bin Amir highlights the challenges in upholding the law and maintaining harmony between religious believers in Indonesia. It also highlights the importance of in-depth analysis in the judicial process and the need for the government, the court, and the community to work together to maintain social harmony and protect the rights of all citizens.

Q: What is the expected outcome of the recommendations?

A: By following the recommendations, it is expected that law enforcement of cases of blasphemy can be carried out fairly and wisely, while encouraging people to respect each other. This will help to maintain social harmony and protect the rights of all citizens.