The Age Limit of Children in the Process of Handling Children of Criminal Acts

Oct 13, 2025 by wbrum.org 130 views

Implications of Material Tests Regarding the Age Limit of Children in the Process of Handling Children of Criminal Acts: Study of Decision Number 1/PUU-VIII/2010

Introduction

Children are the most valuable assets for the future of a nation and state, and it is essential to protect them from any harm or exploitation. In Indonesia, various legal regulations have been enacted to provide protection to children, including Law No. 3 of 1997 concerning Children's Courts. However, the provisions governing the age limit of children to be subject to criminal acts, which is at least 8 years, have raised concerns and criticisms from various parties. This study aims to explore the implications of material tests regarding the age limit of children in the process of handling children of criminal acts, as per Decision Number 1/PUU-VIII/2010.

Background

The protection of children in the judicial process is guaranteed by various national and international instruments, which ensure their rights, freedom, and welfare. For instance, "The Beijing Rules" emphasizes the importance of child protection in the justice system. However, the age limit of 8 years is considered too low and does not protect children, especially when compared to policies in other countries that are more progressive in handling children of criminals. The Indonesian Child Protection Commission (KPAI) and the Medan Child Protection and Protection Center Foundation have urged the government to conduct material tests on this age limit provision.

Methodology

This study employed a normative juridical research method by analyzing secondary data, such as legislation, literature, court decisions, and other relevant sources. A library research approach and qualitative analysis were also used to gain a deep understanding of this issue. The study aimed to answer two important questions: (1) whether Law No. 3 of 1997 has provided sufficient protection for children of criminal acts, and (2) what are the implications of the material test regarding the age limit of the child in the process of handling children of criminal acts.

The Age Limit of Children in the Process of Handling Children of Criminal Acts

The age limit of children to be subject to criminal acts is a critical issue in the process of handling children of criminal acts. The current provision of at least 8 years is considered too low and does not protect children. In contrast, policies in other countries are more progressive in handling children of criminals. For instance, some countries have raised the age limit to 12 years or more, which is considered more appropriate and in line with international standards.

Implications of Material Tests

The material test requested to change the age limit of violators to 12 years is considered very relevant. The implications of this test are significant, as it would provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts. A more detailed arrangement would ensure that the protection of children of criminal acts is more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Suggestions for Updating the Law and Policies

Suggestions submitted include the need for the regulation of the age limit of the child in a special law regarding criminal liability. This would provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts. With a more detailed arrangement, it is expected that the protection of children of criminal acts can be more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the protection of children of criminal acts must be handled seriously, considering their rights and ensuring that the legal process does not ignore their welfare. Thus, steps to update the law and policies related to child protection are very necessary, not only to guarantee justice for children but also to ensure a better future for them.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

The government should conduct a material test to change the age limit of violators to 12 years or more.
A special law regarding criminal liability should be enacted to provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts.
The law and policies related to child protection should be updated to ensure that the protection of children of criminal acts is more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Limitations of the Study

This study has several limitations, including:

The study only focused on the implications of material tests regarding the age limit of children in the process of handling children of criminal acts.
The study did not conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current laws and policies related to child protection.
The study only used secondary data, which may not provide a complete understanding of the issue.

Future Research Directions

Future research should focus on the following areas:

Conducting a comprehensive analysis of the current laws and policies related to child protection.
Examining the implications of the material test on the age limit of children in the process of handling children of criminal acts.
Developing a special law regarding criminal liability to provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts.

References

Law No. 3 of 1997 concerning Children's Courts.
Decision Number 1/PUU-VIII/2010.
"The Beijing Rules".
Indonesian Child Protection Commission (KPAI).
Medan Child Protection and Protection Center Foundation.

Appendix

The appendix includes the following:

List of abbreviations used in the study.
List of references cited in the study.
List of tables and figures used in the study.
List of appendices used in the study.
Q&A: Implications of Material Tests Regarding the Age Limit of Children in the Process of Handling Children of Criminal Acts

Q: What is the current age limit for children to be subject to criminal acts in Indonesia?

A: The current age limit for children to be subject to criminal acts in Indonesia is at least 8 years, as stated in Law No. 3 of 1997 concerning Children's Courts.

Q: Why is the age limit of 8 years considered too low?

A: The age limit of 8 years is considered too low because it does not protect children, especially when compared to policies in other countries that are more progressive in handling children of criminals. Some countries have raised the age limit to 12 years or more, which is considered more appropriate and in line with international standards.

Q: What is the purpose of the material test requested to change the age limit of violators to 12 years?

A: The purpose of the material test is to provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts. A more detailed arrangement would ensure that the protection of children of criminal acts is more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Q: What are the implications of the material test on the age limit of children in the process of handling children of criminal acts?

A: The implications of the material test are significant, as it would provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts. A more detailed arrangement would ensure that the protection of children of criminal acts is more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Q: What are the suggestions submitted to update the law and policies related to child protection?

A: Suggestions submitted include the need for the regulation of the age limit of the child in a special law regarding criminal liability. This would provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts. With a more detailed arrangement, it is expected that the protection of children of criminal acts can be more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Q: Why is it necessary to update the law and policies related to child protection?

A: It is necessary to update the law and policies related to child protection to ensure that the protection of children of criminal acts is more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights. This would also guarantee justice for children and ensure a better future for them.

Q: What are the recommendations made based on the findings of this study?

A: The following recommendations are made:

The government should conduct a material test to change the age limit of violators to 12 years or more.
A special law regarding criminal liability should be enacted to provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts.
The law and policies related to child protection should be updated to ensure that the protection of children of criminal acts is more optimal and in accordance with the principles of human rights.

Q: What are the limitations of this study?

A: This study has several limitations, including:

The study only focused on the implications of material tests regarding the age limit of children in the process of handling children of criminal acts.
The study did not conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current laws and policies related to child protection.
The study only used secondary data, which may not provide a complete understanding of the issue.

Q: What are the future research directions?

A: Future research should focus on the following areas:

Conducting a comprehensive analysis of the current laws and policies related to child protection.
Examining the implications of the material test on the age limit of children in the process of handling children of criminal acts.
Developing a special law regarding criminal liability to provide clarity and legal certainty in the process of handling children of criminal acts.

Q: What are the references used in this study?

A: The references used in this study include:

Law No. 3 of 1997 concerning Children's Courts.
Decision Number 1/PUU-VIII/2010.
"The Beijing Rules".
Indonesian Child Protection Commission (KPAI).
Medan Child Protection and Protection Center Foundation.

Q: What is the appendix of this study?

A: The appendix includes the following:

List of abbreviations used in the study.
List of references cited in the study.
List of tables and figures used in the study.
List of appendices used in the study.