Similar Issues and Intended Behavior

Oct 13, 2025 by wbrum.org 33 views

Bug/Feature Request: Enhancing Video Navigation in Landscape Mode

As a user, navigating through videos in landscape mode can be a frustrating experience, especially when modern phones have wider screens that make it difficult to browse through a list of videos. In this article, we will discuss a bug/feature request that aims to improve video navigation in landscape mode by preventing the minimization of videos when swiping down on UI elements.

The Issue

When swiping down on a video in landscape mode, it is expected to transition to portrait mode. However, occasionally, the video minimizes and goes to the video overview instead. This can be frustrating, especially when it gets locked to landscape mode, making it difficult to switch back to portrait mode without reopening the video and un-fullscreening it.

Similar Issues and Intended Behavior

A similar issue was reported in a different thread, where it was mentioned that this behavior is intended. However, the issue at hand is different, and the intended behavior is not desirable in this case. The issue is not just about the minimization of the video but also about the inability to switch back to portrait mode without reopening the video.

The Request

The request is to add a toggle that prevents the minimization of the player with a swipe down gesture on the UI elements. This would ensure that a swipe down gesture always cleanly un-fullscreens the video into portrait mode, eliminating the frustration of navigating through videos in landscape mode.

Benefits

This feature request would benefit more than 10% of users, not just the person requesting it. It would improve the overall user experience by providing a more seamless and intuitive way of navigating through videos in landscape mode.

Checklist

Before submitting this issue, the following checklist has been completed:

I make sure that there are no existing issues - open or closed - which I could contribute my information to.
I believe this feature request will benefit more than 10% of users, not just myself.

Conclusion

In conclusion, this bug/feature request aims to improve video navigation in landscape mode by preventing the minimization of videos when swiping down on UI elements. This would provide a more seamless and intuitive way of navigating through videos, eliminating the frustration of navigating through videos in landscape mode.

Implementation

To implement this feature, the following steps can be taken:

Add a toggle: Add a toggle that allows users to prevent the minimization of the player with a swipe down gesture on the UI elements.
Modify swipe down gesture: Modify the swipe down gesture to always cleanly un-fullscreens the video into portrait mode when the toggle is enabled.
Test and refine: Test the feature and refine it to ensure that it works as expected and provides a seamless user experience.

Future Development

In the future, this feature can be further developed to include additional features, such as:

Customization: Allow users to customize the behavior of the swipe down gesture, such as changing the threshold for minimization or adding a delay before minimizing the video.
Accessibility: Improve the accessibility of the feature by providing a way for users to enable or disable it using assistive technologies.
Integration: Integrate the feature with other features, such as video playback controls or navigation menus, to provide a more seamless user experience.

Conclusion

Q: What is the current behavior when swiping down on a video in landscape mode?

A: Currently, when swiping down on a video in landscape mode, it is expected to transition to portrait mode. However, occasionally, the video minimizes and goes to the video overview instead.

Q: Why is this behavior a bug/feature request?

A: This behavior is a bug/feature request because it is frustrating and can make it difficult to navigate through videos in landscape mode. The minimization of the video and the inability to switch back to portrait mode without reopening the video are issues that need to be addressed.

Q: Is this behavior intended?

A: According to a similar issue reported in a different thread, this behavior is intended. However, the issue at hand is different, and the intended behavior is not desirable in this case.

Q: What is the proposed solution?

A: The proposed solution is to add a toggle that prevents the minimization of the player with a swipe down gesture on the UI elements. This would ensure that a swipe down gesture always cleanly un-fullscreens the video into portrait mode.

Q: How would this feature benefit users?

A: This feature would benefit more than 10% of users, not just the person requesting it. It would improve the overall user experience by providing a more seamless and intuitive way of navigating through videos in landscape mode.

Q: What are the potential benefits of this feature?

A: The potential benefits of this feature include:

Improved user experience: A more seamless and intuitive way of navigating through videos in landscape mode.
Increased productivity: Users would be able to navigate through videos more efficiently, without the frustration of minimization and inability to switch back to portrait mode.
Enhanced accessibility: The feature would be accessible to users with disabilities, who may rely on assistive technologies to navigate through videos.

Q: How would this feature be implemented?

A: To implement this feature, the following steps can be taken:

Add a toggle: Add a toggle that allows users to prevent the minimization of the player with a swipe down gesture on the UI elements.
Modify swipe down gesture: Modify the swipe down gesture to always cleanly un-fullscreens the video into portrait mode when the toggle is enabled.
Test and refine: Test the feature and refine it to ensure that it works as expected and provides a seamless user experience.

Q: What are the potential challenges of implementing this feature?

A: The potential challenges of implementing this feature include:

Complexity: The feature may require significant changes to the existing codebase, which could be complex and time-consuming to implement.
Testing: The feature would need to be thoroughly tested to ensure that it works as expected and does not introduce any new bugs or issues.
User adoption: Users may need to be educated on how to use the feature, which could be a challenge, especially for users who are not familiar with the existing navigation gestures.

Q: What are the potential future developments for this feature?

A: The potential future developments for this feature include:

Customization: Allow users to customize the behavior of the swipe down gesture, such as changing the threshold for minimization or adding a delay before minimizing the video.
Accessibility: Improve the accessibility of the feature by providing a way for users to enable or disable it using assistive technologies.
Integration: Integrate the feature with other features, such as video playback controls or navigation menus, to provide a more seamless user experience.