Regulation in Positive Law in Indonesia

Oct 13, 2025 by wbrum.org 22 views

Comparison of Criminal Acts of Sexual Deviations According to Positive Law in Indonesia and Islamic Law

The crime of sexual deviations is a serious problem that can threaten the interests of the nation and state. In this context, it is essential to discuss the comparison between positive law in Indonesia and Islamic law regarding the regulation of criminal acts of sexual deviations. This study uses normative legal methods with a focus on legal norms governing this problem. By collecting secondary data from various relevant literature and regulations, this study aims to provide a clear picture of this issue.

Regulation in Positive Law in Indonesia

Regulations regarding the crime of sexual deviations in positive law in Indonesia are regulated in various laws and regulations. Some of them are:

Criminal Code (KUHP): In the Criminal Code, the crime of sexual deviations is regulated in Chapter XIV about crime against politeness. The types of sexual deviations regulated include homosexuals, lesbians, pedophilia, incest, adultery, rape, and exhibitionism. The Criminal Code provides a comprehensive framework for addressing sexual deviations, but its provisions may be considered outdated and in need of revision.
Law No. 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection: This law provides special protection for children from various forms of sexual deviations that can harm them. The law emphasizes the importance of protecting children from sexual abuse and exploitation, but its provisions may not be sufficient to address the complexity of the issue.
Law No. 23 of 2004 concerning the Elimination of Domestic Violence: This law also regulates sexual criminal acts that occur in the context of the household. The law aims to address domestic violence, including sexual abuse, but its provisions may not be effective in preventing such acts.
Law No. 44 of 2008 About Pornography: This provides a legal framework in dealing with actions related to pornography, including those related to sexual deviations. The law regulates pornography, but its provisions may not be sufficient to address the issue of sexual deviations.
Government Regulation in Lieu of Law (Perppu) No. 1 of 2016: This is related to the second amendment of Law No. 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection, strengthening aspects of protection from sexual criminal offenses against children. The regulation aims to strengthen child protection, but its provisions may not be effective in preventing sexual deviations.

Regulation in Islamic Law

On the other hand, Islamic law regulates criminal acts of sexual deviations based on the Qur'an, As-Sunnah, and ijtihad. In the view of Islamic law, this crime is considered a deliberate act, regardless of whether the object of the crime is an adult or children. Islamic law has a firm view of sexual deviations, including severe sanctions for the culprit. Islamic law provides a clear and comprehensive framework for addressing sexual deviations, but its provisions may be considered too harsh and in need of revision.

Social Analysis and Impact

Sexual deviations are very sensitive issues in Indonesia, where people are based on thick religious values. Inappropriate handling of this problem can result in an increase in crime rates and broader social impacts. Therefore, a deep understanding of both positive law and Islamic law in handling criminal acts of sexual deviations is very important. The social impact of sexual deviations can be significant, and it is essential to address the issue in a comprehensive and effective manner.

Positive law in Indonesia seems to be more accommodating aspects of public protection in general, but often considered less strict in responding to cases of sexual deviations. On the other hand, Islamic law provides a more holistic and fundamental solution in overcoming this problem by promoting high moral and ethical values. The comparison between positive law and Islamic law highlights the differences in approaches and emphasis in handling sexual deviations.

Conclusion

Criminal acts of sexual deviation are complex problems and require serious handling. The comparison between positive law in Indonesia and Islamic law shows differences in approaches and emphasis in handling this issue. Islamic law offers a framework of values and solutions that can be considered more in accordance with the norms of religious Indonesian society. Therefore, the integration of Islamic legal values in handling criminal acts of sexual deviations is expected to be an alternative solution that is relevant to fight this crime in the future. The integration of Islamic law values in addressing sexual deviations can provide a more effective and comprehensive solution to this complex problem.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

Revision of the Criminal Code: The Criminal Code should be revised to provide a more comprehensive and effective framework for addressing sexual deviations.
Strengthening Child Protection: The law and regulations related to child protection should be strengthened to provide a more effective framework for protecting children from sexual abuse and exploitation.
Promoting Islamic Law Values: The integration of Islamic law values in addressing sexual deviations can provide a more effective and comprehensive solution to this complex problem.
Public Awareness and Education: Public awareness and education programs should be implemented to raise awareness about the issue of sexual deviations and the importance of addressing it in a comprehensive and effective manner.

By implementing these recommendations, it is expected that the issue of sexual deviations can be addressed in a more effective and comprehensive manner, and the interests of the nation and state can be protected.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Comparison of Criminal Acts of Sexual Deviations According to Positive Law in Indonesia and Islamic Law

This article aims to provide answers to frequently asked questions related to the comparison of criminal acts of sexual deviations according to positive law in Indonesia and Islamic law.

Q1: What is the main difference between positive law in Indonesia and Islamic law in addressing sexual deviations?

A1: The main difference between positive law in Indonesia and Islamic law in addressing sexual deviations is the approach and emphasis. Positive law in Indonesia tends to focus on public protection and punishment, while Islamic law emphasizes the importance of moral and ethical values in addressing the issue.

Q2: What are the types of sexual deviations regulated in the Criminal Code (KUHP)?

A2: The types of sexual deviations regulated in the Criminal Code (KUHP) include homosexuals, lesbians, pedophilia, incest, adultery, rape, and exhibitionism.

Q3: What is the significance of Law No. 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection in addressing sexual deviations?

A3: Law No. 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection provides special protection for children from various forms of sexual deviations that can harm them. The law emphasizes the importance of protecting children from sexual abuse and exploitation.

Q4: How does Islamic law view sexual deviations?

A4: Islamic law views sexual deviations as a deliberate act, regardless of whether the object of the crime is an adult or children. Islamic law has a firm view of sexual deviations, including severe sanctions for the culprit.

Q5: What are the social impacts of sexual deviations in Indonesia?

A5: The social impacts of sexual deviations in Indonesia can be significant, including an increase in crime rates and broader social impacts. Inappropriate handling of this problem can result in social unrest and instability.

Q6: Why is it essential to integrate Islamic law values in addressing sexual deviations?

A6: It is essential to integrate Islamic law values in addressing sexual deviations because Islamic law provides a more holistic and fundamental solution in overcoming this problem by promoting high moral and ethical values.

Q7: What are the recommendations for addressing sexual deviations in Indonesia?

A7: The recommendations for addressing sexual deviations in Indonesia include:

Revision of the Criminal Code to provide a more comprehensive and effective framework for addressing sexual deviations.
Strengthening child protection laws and regulations to provide a more effective framework for protecting children from sexual abuse and exploitation.
Promoting Islamic law values in addressing sexual deviations.
Implementing public awareness and education programs to raise awareness about the issue of sexual deviations and the importance of addressing it in a comprehensive and effective manner.

Q8: What is the significance of public awareness and education in addressing sexual deviations?

A8: Public awareness and education are essential in addressing sexual deviations because they can raise awareness about the issue and promote a culture of respect and tolerance. By educating the public about the importance of addressing sexual deviations, we can create a more supportive and inclusive environment for victims and survivors.

Q9: How can individuals contribute to addressing sexual deviations in Indonesia?

A9: Individuals can contribute to addressing sexual deviations in Indonesia by:

Raising awareness about the issue and promoting a culture of respect and tolerance.
Supporting organizations and initiatives that work to prevent and address sexual deviations.
Reporting cases of sexual deviations to the authorities.
Advocating for policies and laws that protect victims and survivors of sexual deviations.

Q10: What is the future of addressing sexual deviations in Indonesia?

A10: The future of addressing sexual deviations in Indonesia is promising, with the integration of Islamic law values and the implementation of public awareness and education programs. By working together, we can create a more effective and comprehensive framework for addressing this complex issue.